Yankees score big with David Bednar trade – how much will they pay the Pirates and who’s next in their bullpen revamp?

The New York Yankees have made a seismic move at the trade deadline, securing All-Star closer David Bednar from the Pittsburgh Pirates in a deal that could redefine their bullpen. This acquisition addresses their most pressing need, adding a proven late-inning arm with elite credentials.

Bednar’s arrival signals the Yankees’ commitment to reclaiming dominance in the AL East, pairing him with other high-leverage relievers to form a formidable late-game duo. With rumors swirling about additional bullpen upgrades, this trade could be just the first step in a broader overhaul.

The Pirates’ demand for a premium return was met, though the exact price remains undisclosed. As the deadline dust settles, the Yankees’ revamped relief corps is poised to be a key factor in their postseason push.

Yankees Score Big with David Bednar Trade – What Prospects Did They Give Up?

The New York Yankees have finally acquired All-Star closer David Bednar from the Pittsburgh Pirates, but the cost was significant. Reports indicate they surrendered two top-15 prospects, including 21-year-old power-hitting outfielder Jasson Dominguez and right-handed pitcher Chase Hampton. Bednar, with his 2.78 ERA and 14 saves this season, immediately becomes the anchor of the Yankees bullpen.

This is a classic win-now move. Domínguez was blocked in the outfield by Judge and Soto, but Hampton could haunt the Yankees in a few years.

Totally worth it! Bednar’s unhittable splitter solves our late-inning crisis, and we’ve got other prospects like Volpe already producing.

Breaking Down the Trade Package

The Pirates reportedly demanded one of the Yankees’ “untouchable” prospects until the final hours. While Domínguez had been struggling in Triple-A (.231 AVG), his raw power (18 HRs) made him valuable trade bait. Hampton, ranked as the Yankees’ #4 prospect, had a 3.45 ERA in Double-A with elite strikeout numbers (11.2 K/9).

Will Bednar Regain His 2023 Form? Injury Concerns Explored

David Bednar’s 2025 resurgence (1.89 ERA since May) silenced concerns after his early-season struggles and minor league demotion. His fastball velocity has returned to 96.8 mph (+1.4 mph from April), and his whiff rate on the splitter (42.1%) ranks top-5 among relievers. However, his 2024 shoulder inflammation remains a lingering question.

Watch his workload closely. The Pirates babied him after the injury – will Boone overuse him in a tight playoff race?

Maybe, but our training staff fixed Rodón. If they keep Bednar’s appearances to 3-out saves, he’ll dominate.

Who’s Next? Yankees Still Linked to These 3 Bullpen Arms

Despite landing Bednar, GM Brian Cashman remains active in the reliever market:

• Hunter Harvey (WAS) – 1.98 ERA, 97 mph cutter
• Tanner Scott (MIA) – Left-handed flamethrower with 15.1 K/9
• Ryan Helsley (STL) – Experienced playoff closer available

Why Harvey Makes Sense

The Nationals’ right-hander would cost less than Bednar while providing elite swing-and-miss stuff. His 38.5% chase rate pairs well with Bednar’s splitter-heavy approach.

Devin Williams Timeline – When Will the Yankees Have Two Elite Closers?

With Devin Williams (back surgery) beginning rehab assignments, the Yankees could deploy a terrifying late-game combo by September. Williams’ airbender changeup (62% whiff rate in 2024) and Bednar’s splitter would give hitters completely different looks.

Remember 1996 with Wetteland and Rivera? Williams in the 8th and Bednar in the 9th could be even nastier.

I just hope they don’t rush Devin. Back injuries for pitchers are scary – rather have him 100% for October.

Pirates Fans React – How Did Their GM Do in the Trade?

Pittsburgh’s fanbase is deeply divided. Bednar was a hometown hero (Mars, PA native) and clubhouse leader. The return highlights:

Local radio hosts report 68% of fans dislike the deal, despite the prospects’ upside.