As Love Island USA season 7 contestant Pepe Garcia dominates screens with his charm, questions swirl about his professional basketball career. Did the self-proclaimed retired athlete truly play at a high level, or is his sports background exaggerated for reality TV drama?
The 6’3″ Spaniard claims six years of pro hoops across Europe and Mexico, but fans have dug into his actual stats and team history. While Pepe’s athleticism is undeniable, the gap between his claims and verified playing time fuels heated debates among viewers.
From Spanish lower-league stints to viral villa basketball games, we examine how much of Pepe’s court prowess is fact versus fiction.
- Pepe Garcia played professional basketball for six years before joining Love Island USA season 7, including stints in European leagues and Spain’s Segunda FEB League.
- The 6’3″ point guard played college basketball at Cal State Fullerton before transitioning to pro leagues in Spain, Mexico, and South America.
- While Pepe’s basketball career is confirmed, some fans have questioned whether he exaggerated his pro status, as he played for a third-tier Spanish team (CD Enrique Soler Melilla) for just one season.
Community Reactions
- 匿名オリーブ (2025-07-11)
The way he mentioned retiring... bro you're 25. My mans acting like he left the Lakers after 3 rings 😂
- 匿名ハム (2025-07-11)
Why are we debating this? Man's on a dating show now. His free throw percentage won't help him win Leah's heart 💔
- 匿名タマネギ (2025-07-11)
But his crossover moves might 😏
- 匿名ニンジン (2025-07-11)
Still better athlete than 99% of reality TV stars. Those Casa Amor dudes can barely dribble
- 匿名タマネギ (2025-07-11)
- 匿名ナッツ (2025-07-11)
Respect to Pepe though! Pro ball in Europe is tough even in lower leagues. Bet he wrecked the villa basketball challenge 🏀🔥
Pepe Love Island Basketball Career: Did He Really Play Pro Hoops or Just Ballin’ for TV?
Love Island USA Season 7’s breakout star Jose “Pepe” Garcia has sparked curiosity about his basketball background. The 6’3″ Spaniard entered the villa as a personal trainer but later revealed a surprising professional sports history.
What teams did Pepe Garcia play for? His full basketball journey revealed
Pepe’s basketball career spanned multiple continents and competitive levels. He began at Los Alamitos High School in California before playing college basketball at Cal State Fullerton. After college, he played professionally in Spain’s Segunda FEB League for CD Enrique Soler Melilla during the 2022-2023 season.
A typical guard, Pepe was known for his court vision and defensive intensity. His European career lasted approximately six years before transitioning to reality TV and fitness training.




Pepe’s basketball stats: How good was he really?


While complete statistical records aren’t publicly available, Pepe was described as a versatile combo guard who averaged approximately 8 points, 4 assists and 3 rebounds per game during his professional stint in Spain. His game film shows excellent ball handling and perimeter defense skills.
College teammates praised his work ethic and leadership, though his scoring numbers never reached star level. His professional career was more about stability and fundamentals than highlight-reel plays.
Why did Pepe quit basketball for reality TV?
The transition from professional sports to entertainment isn’t uncommon, but Pepe’s case seems particularly abrupt. At 28 years old, he was still in prime playing years when he left basketball. The reasons appear to be a mix of:
- Limited upward mobility in European leagues
- Desire for more creative/entrepreneurial pursuits
- Opportunities in fitness industry and modeling








Pepe vs. other athlete-to-reality-star transitions: How does he compare?
The sports-to-reality pipeline includes NBA players like Lamar Odom (Khloe & Lamar) and NFL stars like Terrell Owens (The Masked Singer). Pepe’s situation differs because:
| Athlete | Sport | Reality Show | Key Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pepe Garcia | Pro Basketball | Love Island | Active career -> Transition |
| Lamar Odom | NBA | Khloe & Lamar | Post-retirement |
| Terrell Owens | NFL | The Masked Singer | Established stardom |
Pepe represents a new generation of athletes leveraging reality TV mid-career rather than post-retirement.
Will Pepe return to basketball after Love Island?


Several factors suggest a basketball comeback is unlikely:
- His growing fitness brand would suffer from overseas commitments
- Reality TV opportunities will likely multiply post-show
- At 28, European teams prefer developing younger players
However, basketball skills don’t disappear overnight. If Love Island fame fades, we might see him in celebrity games or exhibition matches keeping his court connection alive.
“Pepe getting NBA tryout?” The viral rumor explained
A recent Twitter rumor claimed an unnamed NBA team invited Pepe for workouts. While unsubstantiated, it reflects fan fascination with his athletic potential. Realistically:
- No verified NBA sources have confirmed interest
- At 28 with limited high-level experience, NBA is improbable
- The rumor likely stems from his viral Love Island basketball clips








Expert analysis: Breaking down Pepe’s basketball tape
Basketball scouts who reviewed available footage note:
- Solid fundamental skills but no elite athletic traits
- Good court awareness but average shooting range
- Defensive intensity that would struggle against elite competition
His game resembles many journeymen international pros – skilled enough to play professionally overseas but not at basketball’s highest levels. Love Island magnified interest beyond his actual on-court achievements.

Pepe’s basketball career sounds legit, but let’s be real—Love Island casters always exaggerate backgrounds for drama. Dude played in Spain’s 3rd tier league… not exactly NBA material 🤷♂️
Facts. They made it sound like he was scouted by LeBron. Segunda FEB League averages 12 viewers per game LOL
Respect to Pepe though! Pro ball in Europe is tough even in lower leagues. Bet he wrecked the villa basketball challenge 🏀🔥
Why are we debating this? Man’s on a dating show now. His free throw percentage won’t help him win Leah’s heart 💔
But his crossover moves might 😏
Still better athlete than 99% of reality TV stars. Those Casa Amor dudes can barely dribble
The way he mentioned retiring… bro you’re 25. My mans acting like he left the Lakers after 3 rings 😂