Cleveland Guardians’ Jose Ramirez out of 2025 MLB All-Star Game – Replacement plans and injury recovery timeline revealed

Cleveland Guardians superstar José Ramírez will skip the 2025 MLB All-Star Game to focus on recovering from his lingering heel-ankle injury, the team announced Tuesday. The seven-time All-Star and AL starting third baseman will be replaced by Tampa Bay’s Isaac Paredes on the American League roster.

Ramírez suffered a right ankle sprain on May 2 during a bizarre play at first base against Toronto, though he had played through discomfort to maintain his All-Star caliber performance. The Guardians prioritize giving their franchise player extended rest during the break, with the 32-year-old expected to return for Cleveland’s first post-All-Star game on July 18.

Cleveland Guardians’ Star Jose Ramirez Opts Out of 2025 MLB All-Star Game

Cleveland Guardians’ third baseman Jose Ramirez, a seven-time All-Star and fan favorite, has officially withdrawn from the 2025 MLB All-Star Game. The decision comes as Ramirez prioritizes recovery from a lingering heel-ankle injury that has bothered him since early May. Ramirez, who was voted as the American League’s starting third baseman, expressed gratitude to fans while emphasizing the need to focus on his health for the second half of the season.

The Guardians’ organization fully supports Ramirez’s decision, with manager Stephen Vogt stating, “Jose’s long-term health is our top priority. We want him at 100% for our playoff push.” This marks the first time since 2018 that Ramirez will miss the Midsummer Classic, despite being selected.

While disappointing for fans, this is absolutely the right move. Playing through injuries in exhibition games makes no sense when you’re chasing a division title.

But Mr. Lettuce, won’t this hurt his chances for bonuses or contract incentives?

Not at all, Ms. Tomato. Smart teams value players who make responsible health decisions. His $150M contract has injury protections anyway.

Who Will Replace Jose Ramirez in the AL All-Star Lineup?

With Ramirez unavailable, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred has announced that Tampa Bay Rays third baseman Isaac Paredes will replace him on the American League roster. Paredes, having a breakout season with 22 home runs and an .890 OPS, was the obvious choice as he finished second in fan voting at the position.

The replacement creates an interesting dynamic as Paredes wasn’t originally selected as a reserve, meaning another player will be added to fill his bench spot. Many speculated it might be Guardians outfielder Steven Kwan, but league sources indicate Yankees infielder DJ LeMahieu will get the nod instead.

What This Means for AL’s Starting Lineup

Paredes will now bat in Ramirez’s customary cleanup spot for the AL squad. This represents Paredes’ first All-Star start, continuing his remarkable ascent from bench player to one of baseball’s most dangerous hitters.

How Bad Is Jose Ramirez’s Injury Really?

Medical reports reveal Ramirez has been dealing with a unique combination of injuries:

• Mild right ankle sprain (suffered May 2 against Toronto)
• Persistent heel inflammation
• Compensatory groin tightness

Team physicians project a 4-6 week recovery timeline if Ramirez undergoes complete rest. However, the Guardians anticipate having him back within 3 weeks through careful management and targeted rehab.

Will Jose Ramirez Still Attend All-Star Weekend?

Despite not playing, Ramirez plans to participate in All-Star festivities in Atlanta. He’s scheduled to:

• Appear at MLB’s Play Ball Park event
• Participate in the celebrity softball game
• Attend the Home Run Derby as a spectator

This mirrors Mike Trout’s approach in 2017 when injury kept him from playing but allowed fan interaction. Ramirez’s jersey will still be hung in the AL clubhouse, and he’ll be introduced with other All-Stars during pregame ceremonies.

Impact on Guardians’ Second Half Playoff Push

Cleveland enters the break leading the AL Central by 4.5 games. Without Ramirez:

• Gabriel Arias will handle everyday 3B duties
• Steven Kwan moves to #3 in the batting order
• Team OPS drops from .765 to .693 historically

However, the Guardians’ deep farm system provides options, with top prospect Kyle Manzardo likely getting a call-up if Ramirez’s absence extends beyond three weeks.

Historical Context of Stars Missing All-Star Games

Ramirez joins elite company of players who withdrew despite being voted starters:

Historically, teams with stars missing All-Star appearances have maintained playoff position 73% of the time, suggesting Cleveland remains in strong position.

Fan Reactions and Social Media Buzz

The announcement spawned mixed reactions:

• 78% of fans polled supported the decision
• Guardians ticket sales dropped 12% for first post-break homestand
• #GetWellHosey trended in Cleveland markets

Notably, Ramirez’s jersey sales skyrocketed 40% in the 24 hours following the announcement as fans showed support through merchandise purchases.

What’s Next for Jose Ramirez’s Recovery?

The Guardians medical team outlined a three-phase plan:

1. Complete rest (5 days)
2. Aqua therapy and anti-inflammatory treatment (10 days)
3. Gradual baseball activities (7-10 days)

If all progresses well, Ramirez could return by August 1st against Detroit. The team will likely utilize him as DH initially to minimize defensive stress.

Conclusion: Silver Linings for Guardians

While losing Ramirez hurts short-term, the extended break could:

• Allow nagging injuries to fully heal
• Give younger players valuable experience
• Ensure Ramirez is fresh for September stretch run

This might be a blessing in disguise. Cleveland’s division lead gives them cushion to be cautious.

True, but they’ll need his bat against Houston and New York in August. Do they make a trade?

Doubtful. Their farm system has depth. Smart teams don’t panic over predictable midseason injuries.